Banks Brace for More Consumers to Fall Behind on Their Loans

Capital One Financial Corp.

COF -0.68%

set aside roughly $1 billion to cover potential loan losses in the fourth quarter, a 33% increase from the previous quarter.

American Express Co.

AXP 2.71%

increased its reserves by more than 25%, setting aside nearly half a billion dollars. Both had drawn down those rainy-day funds a year earlier.

“We have, of course, a very vigilant eye on the economic environment that we’re moving into,” Capital One Chief Executive

Richard Fairbank

said on a call with analysts this past week.

Consumers have been a bright spot in the economy. They continue to spend at a solid clip in the face of higher inflation, though they cut back during the holidays and added to their savings. And unemployment remains at its lowest level in decades.

But there are signs that some households are coming under pressure. Borrowers have put more purchases on credit cards, but they chipped away at balances at a slower rate. Delinquency rates on credit cards and consumer loans in the fourth quarter approached or hit levels they were at before the pandemic, when stimulus and lower spending on services allowed consumers to bulk up their savings and pay down debt. 

Delinquency rates have surpassed prepandemic levels in some corners of the consumer-lending business. 

At

Ally Financial Inc.,

ALLY -0.59%

the percentage of car loans that were more than 60 days past due rose to 0.89% in the fourth quarter from 0.48% a year earlier.

Discover Financial Services

DFS -0.70%

reported that more than 2% of its private student loans were 30 or more days delinquent, a half-percentage-point increase from a year earlier. Both of those rates were higher than in 2019. 

“I think there are certainly a lot of concerns about what may come with the economy and the potential for a recession in 2023,” Discover Chief Executive

Roger Hochschild

said in an interview. “But where we sit right now, the consumer is still doing pretty well supported by a very strong employment market.”

He added that a rise in demand for products used to consolidate debt could suggest borrowers are more stressed. Discover’s personal-loan balances grew 14% in the fourth quarter from a year earlier.

“We definitely have been tightening our credit standards,” Mr. Hochschild said. “We’re always looking for pockets of stress.” 

The process is a delicate balance for lenders, who can hurt their bottom line if they tighten too much. 

“It can almost be viewed as a high-wire act,” said

Gerard Cassidy,

an analyst at RBC Capital Markets. “On the one hand, you don’t want to be overconservative and shut down lending, but at the same time you don’t want your lending standards to fall by the wayside like in 2006.”

Write to Gina Heeb at [email protected]

Capital One Financial Corp.

COF -0.68%

set aside roughly $1 billion to cover potential loan losses in the fourth quarter, a 33% increase from the previous quarter.

American Express Co.

AXP 2.71%

increased its reserves by more than 25%, setting aside nearly half a billion dollars. Both had drawn down those rainy-day funds a year earlier.

“We have, of course, a very vigilant eye on the economic environment that we’re moving into,” Capital One Chief Executive

Richard Fairbank

said on a call with analysts this past week.

Consumers have been a bright spot in the economy. They continue to spend at a solid clip in the face of higher inflation, though they cut back during the holidays and added to their savings. And unemployment remains at its lowest level in decades.

But there are signs that some households are coming under pressure. Borrowers have put more purchases on credit cards, but they chipped away at balances at a slower rate. Delinquency rates on credit cards and consumer loans in the fourth quarter approached or hit levels they were at before the pandemic, when stimulus and lower spending on services allowed consumers to bulk up their savings and pay down debt. 

Delinquency rates have surpassed prepandemic levels in some corners of the consumer-lending business. 

At

Ally Financial Inc.,

ALLY -0.59%

the percentage of car loans that were more than 60 days past due rose to 0.89% in the fourth quarter from 0.48% a year earlier.

Discover Financial Services

DFS -0.70%

reported that more than 2% of its private student loans were 30 or more days delinquent, a half-percentage-point increase from a year earlier. Both of those rates were higher than in 2019. 

“I think there are certainly a lot of concerns about what may come with the economy and the potential for a recession in 2023,” Discover Chief Executive

Roger Hochschild

said in an interview. “But where we sit right now, the consumer is still doing pretty well supported by a very strong employment market.”

He added that a rise in demand for products used to consolidate debt could suggest borrowers are more stressed. Discover’s personal-loan balances grew 14% in the fourth quarter from a year earlier.

“We definitely have been tightening our credit standards,” Mr. Hochschild said. “We’re always looking for pockets of stress.” 

The process is a delicate balance for lenders, who can hurt their bottom line if they tighten too much. 

“It can almost be viewed as a high-wire act,” said

Gerard Cassidy,

an analyst at RBC Capital Markets. “On the one hand, you don’t want to be overconservative and shut down lending, but at the same time you don’t want your lending standards to fall by the wayside like in 2006.”

Write to Gina Heeb at [email protected]